Thursday, April 10, 2008

Mine vs Yours

This is a debate that probably started when two women, men or whatever sex we were called then, started to contemplate metaphysics and created religion. Which is better? Mine or Yours? I think we are still not sure where the answer lies.

Hinduism is considered by many to be 'a way of life', an 'universal religion'. Growing up in India, you will surely believe this, since there is no true way to explain what being a Hindu is. I have attended the lectures on Gita given by Swami Chinmayanda. Poor soul has since given up speaking, well not because of me, but he answered his call from the powers above. In one lecture he stated the same, 'hinduism is an universal religion'.

Idle mind, they say is a devil's workshop. Well soon i had a letter drafted from my workshop, addressed to the Swamiji, asking him why then should he be worried about the conversion issue (in those days conversion to christianity/islam was a big issue - because of some mass conversions back and forth!!). My question was "If Hinduism is truly an universal religion, then why worry about conversion?".

I got a reply. I wasnt convinced. I wrote back. And i got an explanation update. I still was not convinced. I gave up. I still am not convinced. I admire him for the eloquent way, he explained the Bhagavad Gita. A lot of my thoughts were actually seeds placed by him. I also thank him for taking time out to reply to 'some arbit' me. But then at the end of the day, religion fails when it transcends into politics. This swami was not into politics, but began expressing worries about conversion, islam, christianity, the ganga jal yatra by the BJP etc. I stopped my association with his organization (i had enrolled with his yuva kendra) when he felt we must support the last mentioned program by the BJP.

However, the question remains.... "is your religion better than mine?". I wrote a similar piece but in a different context on my yahoo blog, titled "Blood Religion". But, the question there too, was the same.

2 comments:

--xh-- said...

religion fails when it transcends into politics - agree with you compleetely, CK. when religious belives make way to political games, the sancity of religion fades away.
I belive in all the religions - and i belive all are good.

Convertion is used as a tool by many to get maximum milage in the political war game.

Ranjani Ravi said...

In my humble opinion, I would say that it the Swamiji would have been worried not because of the conversion rate, but because of people's ignorance..

Well, actually, studies say that our religion doesn't have a name at all.Before Christianity and Islam sprung up, a common religion was practised throughout the world and that is supposedly what we call "Hinduism". That's why the Swamiji would have said ours is a universal religion.

If you are into these kinda things, i would suggest that you read Sri Sankaracharya's writings..